I’ve been running a Play by Post game in the Crumbling Keep Discord using Tephrotic Nightmares, a Mork Borg campaign my Luke Gearing. This is the first time I’ve running a PbP in decades, so it all feels like one big experiment.
This blog post by Yochai Gal did a lot to inspire it. It certainly helped me set it up and gave be a base to go off of.
That said, I’ve been learning a lot as we play. One thing that surprised me (and I think will help me with in person games) is how it anchors on old school fame works. When playing in person, I think folks have an expectation that every moment will be full of some sort of roleplay. In reality, it’s more like playing an old school dragon warrior style rpg video game – you’re traveling overground until a random encounter or getting to a location triggers the screen to swirl and put you into battle mode or onto a different map.
In this campaign, most of the pertinent mechanics are geared toward one day as a length of time. You travel a certain amount of hexes during a day, you have to consume your food and water, etc, etc. It’s given me a template for my daily posts.
Now not everything fits into this template. Not every game turn equals a day. Sometimes, the PCs are just fighting skeletons. Each swing doesn’t take a day. When it is a new day, however, this is what
Consume 1 portion of water (1/2 slot) and 1 day of rations.
Wind: Direction
Weather: Weather, dramatically written
Misery Hint
This is where a dramatic recap is written of what the PCs just did.
{Any Accompanying Image, if applicable}
This is where the new information is put.
this is what it looks like in practice:
Entering the Sea of Ash
Your old lives lay behind you now. In a dying world, you are the truly desperate – those who have fled to the sea of Ash. You know only rumors of this place, but you do know it is likely the trouble you had on land will not follow you here.
You’re on your craft with your fellow survivors/ fugitives/ deserters. You do not know these people well, but you can’t afford to be picky with your allies.
The churning black ash lays ahead of you – which way do you go?
Wind: A week wind blows north (Strength 1 – add 1 to speed if going north)
Weather: Overcast and weak with only tepid sunlight.
A safe day, as far as Miseries go – perhaps the only one you’ll ever see

(art from the book. Amazing for scene setting.)
I’m currently running two groups through the same campaign. I’m hoping they’ll eventually run into each other, but we’ll see.
In some ways, it’s like a whole new art form for me, which makes it really exciting for me to explore! Old dogs and new tricks and all that. Yes, a lot of my game design and running is applicable, but it does take tweaks and thoughts as to what makes it interesting and fun. Because of the pace, I think it’s a game that benefits from a bit of paper work – track your inventory, make your map, etc. You only have to draw one hex a day and mark off a ration here and there.
If anyone is interested in looking in on the game, the play channels in the discord are public for viewing. You can get in here.
TAGS: Game Theory, DM Tips
Recent Posts
Fantasy Commander Design Diaries: Sources and Inspirations
Hey, wanna catch up on past posts about Fantasy Commander, my attempt at a Blackmoore-esque game with a terrible title? Find them here. Going into this project, I have a few definitive sources that have
Fantasy Commander Design Diaries: What Should it Do?
Today marks the first email in a series of new design diaries Code named Fantasy Commander, my goal is to make a game reminiscent of Blackmoore with some other influences. Before I start, I
The Snowflake Dungeon Part 28
**Carnival Barker’s Voice** Getch yer lil freaks here! This is a short one today, a continuation of my snowflake dungeon. You can find links to all previous emails about it here. In my last email about
The Snowflake Dungeon Part 27
Rumor tables have become a familiar adventure stand-by. But what are they for? I recently listened to a discussion about putting false entries on rumor tables. (Sadly, I don’t remember the source). Is there fun
The Snowflake Dungeon Part 26
I have been waiting for this moment for months. When I was moving and overwhelmed with all the projects, I was saddest to see this fall by the wayside. My snowflake dungeon. (If you don’t
The Snowflake Dungeon Part 25
If you’ve missed the previous posts about a snowflake dungeon, you can find them here. Its been over a month since I did my last Snowflake Email. I swear, I haven’t forgotten it – I’ve